Publication Ethics
Publication Ethics
Al’Adalah: Journal of Islamic Studies is published by the Center for Research and Community Service (LP2M), Universitas Islam Negeri Kiai Haji Achmad Siddiq Jember, Indonesia. The journal is committed to maintaining academic integrity, editorial independence, and ethical standards throughout the publication process. This statement outlines the responsibilities of editors, authors, reviewers, and the publisher in ensuring the quality and integrity of submitted and published research. The journal's publication ethics policies are informed by the guidance of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and the Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing.
Al’Adalah: Journal of Islamic Studies expects all parties involved in scholarly publication to uphold honesty, originality, fairness, confidentiality, and accountability. Manuscripts are evaluated according to their academic merit, relevance to the journal's Focus and Scope, and compliance with applicable research ethics requirements. The editorial team addresses concerns about research integrity and publication misconduct through fair and appropriate procedures, including corrective action when necessary to maintain the reliability of the published scholarly record.
Duties of the Editor
Publication Decisions
The editorial team of Al’Adalah: Journal of Islamic Studies evaluates submitted manuscripts based on their scholarly merit, originality, methodological rigor, relevance to the journal's Focus and Scope, and contribution to academic knowledge.
Manuscripts that pass the initial editorial screening undergo double-anonymous peer review by at least two qualified and independent reviewers with expertise relevant to the subject of the submission. Editors consider reviewers' evaluations, the quality of the manuscript, and the authors' responses to requested revisions when making editorial decisions.
The Editor-in-Chief holds final responsibility for publication decisions and may consult associate editors, section editors, or additional reviewers when necessary. Where the Editor-in-Chief has a relevant conflict of interest, the decision must be delegated to an authorized editor who can act independently.
Editorial decisions must comply with applicable legal requirements and publication ethics standards. They must remain independent of authors' institutional affiliations, financial considerations, article processing charges, and other interests unrelated to scholarly quality and research integrity.
Fair Play
Editors of Al’Adalah: Journal of Islamic Studies must evaluate submitted manuscripts fairly, consistently, and independently. Editorial assessments and publication decisions must be based on scholarly merit, originality, methodological rigor, the quality of evidence and argumentation, and relevance to the journal's Focus and Scope.
Editors must not discriminate against authors on the basis of race, ethnicity, nationality, citizenship, gender, sexual orientation, religious belief, political opinion, disability, academic position, or institutional affiliation. All submissions must be evaluated according to the same editorial standards, regardless of the authors' professional standing or relationship with the journal.
Editorial decisions must remain independent of improper influence from authors, reviewers, institutional authorities, funding organizations, commercial interests, or other external parties. Editors must apply the journal's policies consistently and manage potential conflicts of interest in accordance with its publication ethics requirements.
Authors must receive clear and respectful communication regarding editorial decisions. Where revisions are requested, editors should provide sufficient guidance to help authors understand the principal issues identified during evaluation. Concerns about procedural fairness may be addressed through the journal's complaints and appeals procedures.
Confidentiality
The editors and any editorial staff must not disclose any information about a submitted manuscript to anyone other than the corresponding author, reviewers, potential reviewers, other editorial advisers, and the publisher, as appropriate.
Disclosure and Conflicts of Interest
Editors and editorial staff must disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest that could compromise their impartiality in handling manuscripts. Such conflicts may arise from financial, personal, professional, institutional, academic, or collaborative relationships with authors or organizations associated with a submission.
Editors must not participate in the evaluation or decision-making process for manuscripts in which they have a conflict of interest. These manuscripts must be assigned to another qualified editor who can manage the review process independently. When the Editor-in-Chief has a conflict of interest, editorial responsibility and the final publication decision must be delegated to an authorized editor without a relevant conflict.
Manuscripts submitted by members of the editorial board must undergo the same scholarly evaluation and peer review standards as other submissions. The submitting editor must not participate in selecting reviewers, evaluating reviewer reports, or making editorial decisions concerning their own manuscript.
Editors must maintain the confidentiality of unpublished manuscripts and must not use information or ideas obtained during editorial evaluation for personal research or other purposes without the authors' explicit written consent.
Editorial decisions must be based on scholarly merit, relevance to the journal's Focus and Scope, and the integrity of the research. Financial considerations, including article processing charges, must not influence manuscript evaluation, reviewer selection, or publication decisions. The editorial team should document the management of relevant conflicts of interest to ensure accountability and procedural fairness.
Management of Unethical Behavior
Al’Adalah: Journal of Islamic Studies takes allegations of research and publication misconduct seriously, whether they concern submitted manuscripts or published articles. The editorial team will consider reports of suspected plagiarism, data fabrication or falsification, redundant publication, inappropriate authorship, undisclosed conflicts of interest, breaches of research ethics, manipulation of peer review, and other practices that may compromise the integrity of scholarly publication. Concerns may be reported by authors, reviewers, readers, editors, or other parties, including after an article has been published.
The Editor-in-Chief or an editor without a relevant conflict of interest will conduct an initial assessment of the concern and the available evidence. Where appropriate, the editorial team will contact the individuals concerned, request an explanation or supporting documentation, and provide a reasonable opportunity to respond. Allegations will be assessed fairly and confidentially, without presuming misconduct before the relevant evidence has been examined.
When concerns require formal investigation beyond the journal's authority or expertise, the editorial team may refer the matter to the relevant research institution or other competent body and cooperate with its investigation. The journal may also seek independent expert advice when necessary. Editors involved in the alleged misconduct or affected by a conflict of interest must not participate in handling the case.
Editorial action will depend on the nature and seriousness of the concern and the evidence available. For manuscripts under consideration, possible actions include requesting clarification or revision, suspending editorial processing, or rejecting the submission. For published articles, the journal may issue a correction, an expression of concern, or a retraction when warranted. Such actions will follow the journal's policies on corrections and retractions and relevant guidance from the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).
The editorial team will document the handling and outcome of reported concerns, protect confidential information where appropriate, and take reasonable steps to preserve the integrity of the scholarly record. Reports submitted in good faith will be considered regardless of when the potential misconduct is identified.
Duties of Authors
Reporting Standards
Authors must present their research accurately, clearly, and transparently. Manuscripts should explain the research problem, relevant sources, methodological or analytical approach, findings or arguments, and scholarly contribution in sufficient detail to allow readers and reviewers to evaluate the credibility of the research.
Reporting standards should reflect the nature of the research. Empirical studies should provide appropriate information about data collection, source or participant selection, and analytical procedures. Historical, normative, conceptual, theoretical, and comparative studies should clearly identify their principal sources, explain their methods of interpretation or reasoning, and provide sufficient evidence to support their arguments.
Authors must represent evidence and scholarly sources accurately, acknowledge relevant uncertainties or qualifications, and distinguish their own interpretations from claims established by the sources. Fabrication, falsification, misleading presentation of evidence, and deliberate omission or distortion of relevant information are unacceptable.
Authors should ensure that conclusions are consistent with the evidence and analysis presented. Where research materials cannot be disclosed because of privacy, confidentiality, legal, or ethical restrictions, authors should comply with the journal's Data Access and Retention and Research Ethics and Ethical Oversight policies.
Data Access and Retention
Authors should provide sufficient information to support the transparency and verification of their research. Where appropriate, supporting data may be deposited in recognized repositories or made available upon reasonable request. Authors should retain relevant research materials in accordance with applicable ethical, legal, and institutional requirements.
Data sharing must respect participant privacy, confidentiality, informed consent, and other applicable restrictions. Authors are not required to disclose identifiable participant information, confidential interview transcripts, or materials whose disclosure could cause harm or violate ethical or legal obligations. Where data cannot be shared, authors should explain the relevant restrictions.
Originality and plagiarism
Authors must submit original scholarly work and acknowledge all sources used in developing their research, arguments, and findings. The use of another person's words, ideas, data, interpretations, images, or other intellectual contributions without appropriate acknowledgment constitutes plagiarism and is unacceptable. This requirement also applies to paraphrased or translated materials.
Authors must disclose relevant overlap between a submitted manuscript and their previous publications, including substantial reuse of text, data, or arguments. The reuse of previously published material must be appropriately acknowledged and must not misrepresent earlier work as a new scholarly contribution. The editorial team will assess potential text recycling and redundant publication according to the nature, extent, and context of the overlap.
Al’Adalah: Journal of Islamic Studies uses Turnitin to screen submitted manuscripts for textual similarity. Similarity reports are evaluated by editors in context, considering the sources, extent, location, and nature of matching material and the adequacy of attribution. A similarity percentage alone does not establish whether plagiarism has occurred, and no single similarity threshold automatically determines manuscript acceptance or rejection.
Authors must confirm the originality of their submissions and disclose any relevant prior dissemination or related publications during the submission process. Where potential plagiarism or inappropriate overlap is identified, the editorial team may request clarification or revision, reject the manuscript, or take other appropriate action in accordance with the journal's publication ethics policies. Authors will be given a reasonable opportunity to respond to substantive concerns.
Detailed screening procedures and editorial actions are provided in the journal's Plagiarism and Originality Policy.
Multiple, Redundant, or Concurrent Publication
Authors must not submit the same manuscript to more than one journal simultaneously or submit work that has already been published as an original article elsewhere. Duplicate or redundant publication, including substantial republication of previously published findings, arguments, or materials without appropriate disclosure and acknowledgment, is unacceptable.
Authors must disclose any closely related publications, manuscripts under consideration elsewhere, or previous dissemination of the research, including preprints, conference papers, theses, dissertations, and publications in other languages. Previous dissemination does not necessarily constitute redundant publication. The editorial team will assess the nature and extent of any overlap, the originality of the submitted contribution, and its implications for the journal's editorial and peer review procedures.
Manuscripts developed from earlier research must clearly acknowledge relevant previous work and demonstrate a substantive scholarly contribution. Authors must not divide substantially overlapping research into multiple publications in ways that misrepresent the originality or significance of the findings.
Where suspected redundant or concurrent publication is identified, the editorial team may request clarification and supporting documentation, consult relevant publication records, or take a
Acknowledgment of Sources
Authors must appropriately acknowledge the scholarly works, sources, and intellectual contributions that inform their research. All quotations, paraphrases, interpretations, data, and arguments derived from other sources must be accurately attributed. Citations should enable readers to identify and verify the sources used, in accordance with the journal's referencing requirements.
Research involving Islamic primary sources, classical texts, historical manuscripts, archival materials, or translated works must provide sufficient information to identify the relevant texts, editions, translations, or archival collections. Authors must accurately represent the content and context of these sources and clearly distinguish their own interpretations from those of the original authors or translators.
Information obtained through private conversations, correspondence, interviews, or other non-public communications must be used in accordance with applicable requirements concerning informed consent, confidentiality, and research ethics. Authors must obtain appropriate permission before disclosing identifiable or confidential information and must respect any restrictions agreed upon with participants or information providers.
Authors must not use unpublished manuscripts, research proposals, or other confidential materials obtained through peer review, editorial responsibilities, grant evaluation, or similar privileged activities without appropriate authorization and the relevant rights holder's explicit permission.
Authors are responsible for obtaining permission to reproduce third-party copyrighted materials where required and for providing appropriate acknowledgments. The editorial team may request clarification, documentation, or corrections when source attribution, permissions, or the representation of source materials raise concerns.
Authorship and Contributions
Authorship should be limited to individuals who have made substantial intellectual contributions to the research and manuscript, have reviewed and approved the version submitted for publication, and agree to take responsibility for their contributions and the integrity of the work. All individuals who meet the journal's authorship criteria should be included as authors. Individuals who do not meet these criteria but have provided research assistance, technical support, language editing, or other relevant contributions may be acknowledged with their permission.
Al’Adalah: Journal of Islamic Studies requires authors to provide a statement describing their individual contributions using the CRediT (Contributor Roles Taxonomy) framework, as specified in the manuscript template. Contribution statements should accurately reflect each author's role and be approved by all co-authors. The assignment of a CRediT role does not automatically establish eligibility for authorship.
Guest, gift, and ghost authorship are unacceptable. Authors must not include individuals who have made no qualifying intellectual contribution or omit individuals who meet the authorship criteria. The corresponding author is responsible for ensuring that all co-authors have approved the manuscript, agreed to its submission, and consented to the authorship and contribution statements.
Any request to add, remove, or rearrange authors after submission must be submitted to the editorial office with a clear explanation and written agreement from all affected and existing authors, including any author being added or removed. The editorial team will evaluate the request before approving changes to the authorship record. Where disagreements remain unresolved, the journal may suspend editorial processing and refer the matter to the relevant institutions. Requests for authorship changes after publication will be assessed in accordance with publication ethics guidance and may require a formal correction to the published record.
Fundamental Errors in Published Works
Authors who discover significant errors or inaccuracies in their published articles must promptly inform the editorial team of Al’Adalah: Journal of Islamic Studies. They should provide a clear explanation of the problem, identify the affected parts of the article, and submit relevant supporting information. Authors are expected to cooperate with the editorial team in assessing the error and determining the appropriate corrective action.
When concerns about a published article are raised by readers, reviewers, editors, or other parties, the authors must respond to reasonable editorial inquiries and provide clarification or supporting evidence where necessary. The editorial team will assess the nature and significance of the reported problem, considering its implications for the reliability of the article's findings, interpretations, and conclusions.
Depending on the circumstances, the journal may issue a correction, an expression of concern, or a retraction in accordance with its editorial policies and relevant guidance from the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). The Editor-in-Chief, or an authorized independent editor when a conflict of interest exists, is responsible for determining the appropriate editorial action.
Corrections and other post-publication notices should be clearly identified, publicly accessible, and linked to the original article where applicable. Substantive changes to the published scholarly record must be documented transparently.
Research Ethics and Ethical Oversight
Authors conducting research involving human participants must comply with applicable ethical and legal requirements, including institutional ethics review where required. Researchers should obtain informed consent when appropriate and take reasonable measures to protect participants' privacy, confidentiality, and welfare. Research involving minors, vulnerable individuals, or sensitive personal information requires particular care. Manuscripts should disclose relevant ethical approval or exemption, or explain why formal ethics review was not required.
Research involving interviews, observations, online interactions, social media content, or other materials concerning identifiable individuals must consider the potential risks of disclosure. Public accessibility of digital content does not automatically eliminate ethical responsibilities. Authors should use appropriate anonymization and obtain permission to publish identifiable personal information, quotations, or images where required.
Research based on publicly available legal texts, historical documents, or other non-personal documentary sources does not ordinarily require human-participant ethics approval. Authors must nevertheless observe relevant requirements concerning source attribution, copyright, archival access, and research integrity. Where research involves animals, medical interventions, or hazardous procedures, authors must comply with the applicable discipline-specific ethical standards and regulations.
The editorial team may request clarification or supporting documentation concerning ethical approval, informed consent, participant protection, or other relevant ethical considerations.
Declaration of Competing Interests
All authors must disclose any financial or non-financial interests that could influence, or reasonably be perceived to influence, the research, interpretation of findings, or presentation of arguments. Relevant interests may include financial relationships, employment, consultancy, organizational affiliations, personal or professional relationships, academic collaborations, and other commitments directly related to the subject of the manuscript.
Authors must provide a competing interests declaration at the time of submission, including an explicit statement when no competing interests exist. The corresponding author is responsible for ensuring that all co-authors have reviewed and approved the declaration. Authors must promptly inform the editorial team of any relevant changes during the editorial and publication process.
Authors must also disclose all sources of financial support in a separate funding statement, including the names of funding organizations and the role of sponsors, where applicable, in the research design, data collection, analysis, interpretation, manuscript preparation, or publication decisions. When no external funding was received, this should be stated explicitly.
The disclosure of a competing interest does not automatically disqualify a manuscript from publication. The editorial team will evaluate the relevance of declared interests and determine whether additional clarification or measures are necessary to protect the integrity and independence of the editorial process.
Competing interests and funding declarations must be consistent with the information provided during submission and in the final published manuscript. Authors should preserve the anonymity of the manuscript during double-anonymous peer review by providing identifying disclosures separately when necessary.
Image Integrity
Authors must ensure that photographs, manuscript reproductions, archival documents, screenshots, maps, graphs, and other visual materials accurately represent the sources or evidence used in their research. Visual materials must not be fabricated, selectively altered, or presented in ways that mislead readers or distort the interpretation of research findings.
Adjustments to brightness, contrast, color, size, or image cropping are acceptable when necessary to improve clarity, provided that they do not remove, obscure, or misrepresent relevant information. Substantive modifications, image composites, or other alterations that may affect interpretation must be clearly disclosed. Authors must not present digitally generated or reconstructed images as authentic documentary or empirical evidence.
Authors must provide appropriate captions, source attribution, and information about the provenance of visual materials. Permission to reproduce copyrighted images or documents must be obtained where required. When visual materials involve identifiable individuals, private communications, or sensitive information, authors must comply with applicable requirements concerning consent, confidentiality, and participant protection.
Authors should retain original visual materials and relevant documentation where reasonably possible. The editorial team may request original files or additional information to verify the authenticity and accuracy of submitted images, subject to applicable ethical, legal, and confidentiality restrictions. Suspected inappropriate image manipulation will be assessed in accordance with the journal's publication ethics procedures.
Duties of Reviewers
Contribution to Editorial Decisions
Peer review assists the editor in making editorial decisions and, through editorial communications with the author, may also assist the author in improving the paper.
Promptness
Any selected referee who feels unqualified to review the research reported in a manuscript or knows its prompt review will be impossible should notify the editor and excuse themselves from the review process.
Confidentiality
Any manuscripts received for review must be treated as confidential documents. They must not be shown to or discussed with others except as authorized by the editor.
Standards of Objectivity
Reviews should be conducted objectively. Personal criticism of the author is inappropriate. Referees should express their views clearly with supporting arguments.
Acknowledgment of Sources
Reviewers should identify relevant scholarly works, primary sources, or significant academic arguments that have not been adequately acknowledged in the manuscript. Recommendations for additional references must be based on their relevance to the research problem, analysis, or scholarly contribution. Reviewers should explain why particular sources deserve consideration, especially when they may affect the manuscript's interpretation of previous research or claims of originality.
Reviewers must not require authors to cite their own publications or those of colleagues solely to increase citation counts or academic visibility. Citation recommendations should reflect scholarly relevance and the needs of the manuscript.
Reviewers who identify substantial similarities between the submitted manuscript and previously published or publicly available work should inform the editor and provide relevant references or supporting information where possible. Suspected plagiarism, redundant publication, or inappropriate use of sources must be reported through the journal's confidential editorial procedures without making unsupported accusations.
Reviewers must respect the confidentiality of unpublished manuscripts and must not use privileged information obtained during peer review for personal or professional advantage.
Disclosure and Conflicts of Interest
Reviewers must disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest that could compromise, or reasonably appear to compromise, the independence and impartiality of their evaluation. Such conflicts may arise from financial, personal, professional, institutional, academic, intellectual, or collaborative relationships with the authors or organizations associated with the manuscript.
Reviewers should decline invitations when they are employed at the same institution as any of the authors or have recently maintained close collaborative, supervisory, or joint research funding relationships with them, including relationships within the preceding three years. Reviewers must also decline assignments when personal relationships, direct academic competition, financial interests, or involvement in the research prevent an independent assessment.
Reviewers must inform the editor promptly if a potential conflict becomes apparent after accepting an invitation. Under the journal's double-anonymous peer review process, reviewers who recognize or suspect an author's identity should notify the editor if this creates a possible conflict of interest. Reviewers must not attempt to identify anonymous authors.
When uncertainty exists about a potential conflict, reviewers should disclose the relevant circumstances and seek editorial guidance before proceeding. The editorial team will assess the disclosure and determine whether the reviewer may continue or whether the manuscript should be reassigned. Reviewers must not continue the evaluation while a potentially disqualifying conflict remains unresolved.
Reviewers must maintain the confidentiality of manuscripts and must not use unpublished information, research findings, or ideas obtained during peer review for personal, professional, or competitive advantage.